The 5 Best Renters Insurance Georgia Companies: Pros & Cons 

Renters insurance Georgia safeguards tenants and their belongings from unexpected events such as extreme weather, vandalism, or theft. Whether you’re renting an apartment in Atlanta or a home in Savannah, it’s a cost-effective way to ensure stability amidst potential calamities. While many view renters insurance as standard, providers can differ in coverage, cost, and customer service quality. 

Based on thorough analysis, we’ve identified Georgia’s top renters insurance providers:

  • Lemonade: Ideal for college students.
  • Geico: Best for straightforward policy management.
  • State Farm: Preferred for cost-effective premiums.
  • Allstate: Top choice for seniors.
  • Amica: Best for customer service 

Best Renters Insurance Georgia Companies

Lemonade Renters Insurance

Why We Chose Lemonade

We gave Lemonade a high rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars for its affordable yet thorough renters insurance and speedy claim handling. As a fully online insurer, Lemonade operates mainly through its user-friendly website and app, available for both iOS and Android. Signing up is a breeze, taking just about 90 seconds, making it easy even if you’re not super tech-savvy.

However, since Lemonade uses AI technology, there’s no in-app option to chat with a live agent. But if you need extra help, you can always call their toll-free number at 1 (844) 733-8666.

Lemonade Renters Insurance

Pros and Cons


  • You can get discounts for having safety devices like smoke alarms, security systems, and fire extinguishers.
  • Signing up is quick, usually taking just about 90 seconds.
  • Money from unused premiums goes to charity through their giveback program.


  • They’re newer on the scene compared to other providers.
  • They don’t have local agents for direct help.

Discounts and Endorsements

Based on a quote from Atlanta, GA, Lemonade’s average price is $260 a year.

  • Discounts: Savings for bundling policies, paying yearly, and having safety devices.
  • Extra Coverages: Protection for water damage, damage to the landlord’s property, expensive items, and coverage for a significant other.


Why We Chose Amica 

For exceptional service in Georgia, we suggest renters consider Amica. Highly esteemed nationwide, Amica earned a 5/5 in our service ratings, a score rivaled only by USAA.

Amica’s customer service also garners praise elsewhere. The NAIC highlighted its commendable Complaint Index at 0.51, indicating it receives significantly fewer complaints relative to its size compared to other insurers.


Yet, premium service comes at a premium price. Amica’s average monthly rate of $29 is notably higher than our top recommendation and slightly above Georgia’s average.

To potentially lower costs, renters might consider policy bundling. Amica provides car insurance alongside renters coverage, allowing for significant savings and streamlined billing when combined.

Pros & Cons 


  • Exceptional Service: Amica is recognized for its top-tier customer service and has received high ratings in this regard.
  • Low Complaint Index: As per the NAIC, Amica has a notably low Complaint Index, meaning it has fewer complaints relative to its size than many competitors.
  • Bundling Opportunities: Renters can benefit from potential discounts by bundling Amica’s renters insurance with their car insurance.
  • Reputation: Among the best-rated insurers in the country, ensuring reliability and trustworthiness.


  • Higher Premiums: Amica’s premium service tends to come at a higher price point, with its monthly rates often being above the state average.
  • Limited Offerings: While known for its renters and auto insurance, Amica might not have as diverse a range of insurance offerings as some larger competitors.

Discounts and Endorsements

Here’s a breakdown of potential discounts and endorsements for Amica renters insurance:

  • Bundling Discount: Combining renters insurance with other policies like auto insurance can lead to savings.
  • Loyalty Discount: Extended policyholding with Amica could fetch you a discount.
  • Claims-Free Discount: If you haven’t filed a claim for a specified period, you may be eligible for a reduction in premiums.
  • Auto-Pay: Opting for automated payment methods might fetch you a discount.
  • Protective Devices: Having safety devices like smoke detectors, security systems, or fire alarms in your rented space can result in discounts.
  • Valuable Items Coverage: Extended coverage for high-value items like jewelry, artwork, or electronics that might exceed the standard policy limits.
  • Identity Theft Protection: Coverage that helps with the costs associated with restoring your identity.
  • Personal Property Replacement Cost: Instead of depreciated value, this endorsement ensures you get the full replacement cost for lost or damaged items.
  • Water Backup: Provides coverage if water backs up through drains or overflows from a sump pump.

GEICO Renters Insurance

Why We Chose Geico

While Geico is best known for car insurance, they also offer renters insurance through other companies. With agents in almost every city in Georgia, it’s a good choice if you like face-to-face service. We gave Geico a 4.8 out of 5 rating, praising its excellent customer support, discount options, and strong financial reliability.

However, all claims are managed by the company that actually insures you, like Assurant, Chubb, or Liberty Mutual. When you sign up, you don’t get to pick which of these companies covers you.

GEICO Renters Insurance

Pros and Cons


  • If you have Geico car insurance, you can get big savings by bundling it with renters insurance.
  • They have a handy mobile app that lets you file claims easily and connect with local agents.
  • Their website has a tool to help you estimate the value of your belongings and find the right coverage.


  • They use other companies to actually provide the insurance.
  • If you have a claim, you deal with the other company, not Geico.

Discounts and Endorsements 

  • Discounts: Savings for bundling with auto insurance and having safety devices.
  • Extra Coverages: Cash payout for personal property, coverage for business items, and added protection for specific personal belongings.

Related article:

Best Insurance Providers In Orlando (2023)

What Is Term Life Insurance?

State Farm Renters Insurance

Why We Chose State Farm

In 2021, State Farm was a major player in the property insurance world, holding 8.82% of the market. They’re known for their strong financial standing, with an A rating from AM Best, and their wide range of renters insurance choices. We rated State Farm 4.7 out of 5 because of their solid coverage for personal items, few customer complaints, and many additional coverage options.

State Farm Renters Insurance

Pros and Cons


  • They cover damage from household pets.
  • There’s no limit on coverage for personal items and if you can’t use your place.
  • All plans include protection from storm damage.


  • The more affordable plans offer only basic coverage.
  • Extra coverages and add-ons tend to cost more.

Discounts and Endorsements

 Based on data from Quadrant Information Services, State Farm’s average annual price is $209.

  • Discounts: Savings for bundling policies, using auto-pay, having safety devices, and a record of no claims.
  • Extra Coverages: Support for identity theft recovery, coverage for business items, and higher protection limits for specific personal belongings.

Allstate Renters Insurance

Why We Chose Allstate

Allstate, a top U.S. insurer, earned a 4.6 out of 5 rating for its unique three-tiered plan approach and valuable extra coverages. However, it was the priciest option for renters in Georgia in our study.

Despite its cost, Allstate is ideal for first-time renters uncertain about their coverage needs. Allstate offers three tailored policy options with every quote, balancing coverage with deductibles. Additionally, they provide a free online tool to help renters estimate the replacement cost of their belongings, aiding in selecting the right coverage amount.

Allstate Renters Insurance

Pros and Cons


  • Provides a variety of discount opportunities.
  • Features an online center for understanding renters insurance.
  • Lets customers pick between RCV (Replacement Cash Value) and ACV (Actual Cash Value) coverage.


  • In certain Georgia cities, you might need to reach out to a local agent for a quote.
  • Uses a different deductible for natural disasters.

Discounts and Endorsements

Based on data from Quadrant Information Services, Allstate’s average yearly rate is $472.

  • Discounts: Savings for bundling with auto insurance, discounts for seniors, using auto-pay, having safety devices, and maintaining a claim-free record.
  • Extra Coverages: Enhanced protection for expensive items, coverage for business belongings, and support for identity theft recovery.

What Does Renters Insurance Cover?

Unlike homeowners insurance, renters insurance does not provide coverage for the structure of your home, unit, or building. This responsibility falls under your landlord’s insurance policy. Instead, renters insurance is designed to protect your personal belongings from a range of risks and also provides coverage for injuries or damages for which you may be held liable. In addition to covering your personal property, renters insurance includes provisions for medical payments and additional living expenses, which can help cover costs incurred when you are displaced from your home due to a covered loss.

Standard renters insurance offers protection for your belongings in the event of damage or destruction caused by the following perils:

  • Fire and smoke damage
  • Lightning
  • Windstorms and hail
  • Vandalism
  • Theft
  • Sudden or accidental water damage
  • Weight of ice, snow, or sleet
  • Frozen pipes

It’s important to note that standard renters insurance typically does not include coverage for flood damage or earthquakes, but you may have the option to add these coverages for an additional premium.

Why You Need Renters Insurance Georgia

While Georgia law doesn’t mandate renters insurance, many landlords deem it essential for tenancy. Given its affordability relative to the protection it offers, there’s a compelling case for acquiring it. Georgia’s Office of Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire recommends that all renters obtain insurance, emphasizing, “Tenants should secure insurance for their personal belongings and need protection against potential liabilities harming others or their properties.”

What Are Common Causes for Renters Insurance Claims in Georgia?

In Georgia, as with many places, renters insurance claims often arise from a variety of incidents. Common causes for claims include:

  • Theft or Burglary: Given that properties, especially in urban areas, can be targets for burglars, theft remains a primary reason renters file claims.
  • Fire and Smoke Damage: Accidental fires, whether from faulty wiring, unattended candles, or kitchen mishaps, can cause significant damage to personal property.
  • Water Damage: This might result from issues like burst pipes, faulty appliances, or leaky roofs. It’s important to note that while renters insurance typically covers water damage from such incidents, it usually doesn’t cover flooding from external sources.
  • Liability Claims: If someone gets injured within a renter’s residence, they might file a claim against the renter. Renters insurance can cover these liability claims, helping with medical bills or legal fees.
  • Weather-related Damage: While renters insurance might not cover flooding, it often covers other weather-related damages. Georgia, being susceptible to storms, can experience damages from wind, hail, or even tornados.
  • Vandalism: Damage intentionally caused to a renter’s property by others falls under this category. 

5 Factors Affect Renters Insurance Georgia

Renters insurance premiums are influenced by various factors. Key determinants include your rental’s location, your credit score, and the specific policy choices you opt for.

Location and Home Risk Level

The location of your rental property significantly influences your monthly premium, mainly due to local crime rates and weather-related risks. For instance, a rental in Sea Island may have a higher premium because of its closeness to the coast, increasing the hurricane risk. Similarly, properties in Georgia areas with elevated crime rates will likely have higher insurance costs due to the heightened risk of burglary or theft.

Credit Score

No matter where you are, many renters insurance providers consider your credit score when setting your premium. Studies indicate that those with lower credit scores often file more insurance claims than those with better scores. Thus, insurers might charge higher premiums to renters with weaker credit histories due to their higher claim probability. Conversely, renters boasting good credit typically enjoy lower rates.

Coverages, Deductibles and Discounts

The deductible is the amount you’ll pay out-of-pocket before your insurance covers a claim. For renters insurance, typical deductibles vary between $500 and $5,000. Opting for a higher deductible usually results in a lower premium, and the opposite holds true with a lower deductible.

Georgia Renters Insurance: Frequently asked questions 

How much is renters insurance in Georgia?

The average annual cost for renters insurance in Georgia is $323. Yet, by comparing quotes and fine-tuning your policy’s coverage or deductible, you can notably lower this expense.

Is renters insurance a requirement in Georgia?

While some Georgia landlords might mandate renters insurance as part of the lease agreement, there’s no legal obligation to have it. However, we advise securing renters insurance as an affordable safeguard for your belongings during tenancy. Check out our recommended insurers in Georgia.

How long does it take for renters insurance to take effect?

Typically, renters insurance can take effect almost immediately. Once you’ve chosen a policy, completed the application, and made the initial payment, your coverage can start as soon as the same day or on a specified future date you’ve chosen. However, always confirm with your insurance provider about the exact starting time of your coverage.

Do college students need renters insurance? 

While college students aren’t legally required to have renters insurance, it’s often a wise choice. If they live in off-campus housing, their possessions won’t be covered by their parents’ homeowners or renters insurance. On-campus housing might offer some coverage, but it could be limited. Renters insurance ensures their personal belongings are protected from theft, damage, or other unforeseen incidents.

Is renters insurance worth it? 

Absolutely. Renters insurance is relatively inexpensive but can save you significant money and stress in the event of theft, damage, or liability claims. It not only covers personal property but can also offer liability protection if someone gets injured in your rental unit. Given the potential high cost of replacing belongings or facing legal claims without insurance, the modest investment in a renters policy is typically well worth it.


We collected 175 quotes from seven top insurance providers in Georgia, covering 25 major cities or areas. These quotes were based on the profile of a 30-year-old single man without recent renters insurance claims.

Our chosen coverage levels included:

  • Personal property: $30,000
  • Liability: $100,000
  • Medical payments: $1,000
  • Deductible: $500
  • Loss of use: $0

Our top picks are determined by our experts who assess rates, customer service, and coverage options. The star ratings for renters insurance draw from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Complaint Index, the J.D. Power customer satisfaction index, and rankings from ValuePenguin’s editors.

The Bottom Line

The ideal renters insurance should align with your coverage requirements and budget. For numerous Georgia renters, Lemonade stands out due to its swift online registration, reasonable rates, and user-friendly mobile app. However, no matter your chosen insurer, it’s always wise to compare quotes from several trusted providers to gain a broader perspective on available market options.

Leave a Reply