Comprehensive Auto Insurance: A Breakdown Details

Comprehensive auto insurance is a crucial component of a well-rounded car insurance policy, providing protection against a wide range of non-collision-related incidents, from theft and vandalism to natural disasters and falling objects.

Key Takeaways

  • Comprehensive auto insurance helps pay for fixing your car if something other than a crash damages it.
  • If you get a loan to buy a car, you might have to buy both comprehensive and collision coverage.
  • Getting comprehensive coverage might not be a good idea if you own an older car that’s not worth much anymore.
  • Comprehensive insurance takes care of your car if animals, trees, natural disasters, thieves, or vandals harm it. It doesn’t help with damage to other cars or people.
  • If you increase the amount you’ll pay before your insurance kicks in for comprehensive claims (called a deductible), you might pay less for your premiums.

What Is Comprehensive Auto Insurance?

Comprehensive insurance for your car is like a safety net. It helps when your car gets hurt, but not in a crash. It’ll pay for things like a tornado wrecking your car, a deer bumping into it, someone vandalizing it with paint, or if your car gets damaged during a break-in. Even if your garage falls on your car, this insurance can help. It covers many different types of damage, not just accidents.

What Is Comprehensive Auto Insurance?

What does Comprehensive Auto Car Insurance Cover?

Comprehensive insurance takes care of many types of damage. This includes things like:

What does Comprehensive Auto Car Insurance Cover?

Hitting animals, like deer

If you accidentally collide with an animal, like a deer or a raccoon, comprehensive insurance can help cover the repair costs for the damage to your car. This is because it’s considered an unexpected incident that isn’t a traditional car accident.

Natural disasters such as earthquakes, floods, and hurricanes

Comprehensive insurance provides protection if your car is damaged by natural disasters like earthquakes, floods, hurricanes, or even things like tornadoes. These are events beyond your control that can cause significant harm to your vehicle.

Fires damaging your car

If your car is damaged or destroyed by a fire, whether it’s due to an accident, arson, or any other reason, comprehensive insurance can help cover the costs of repairs or replacement.

Damage from riots or vandalism

In case your car is harmed during a riot or is intentionally vandalized, comprehensive insurance steps in to assist with the expenses to repair the damages. It’s there to protect against acts of vandalism and civil unrest.

If your whole car or some parts get stolen

Comprehensive insurance covers the theft of your entire vehicle or specific parts of it. If your car is stolen or parts like the stereo, wheels, or catalytic converter are stolen, comprehensive coverage can help replace what’s been taken.

Fixing broken windshields 

Comprehensive insurance can pay for repairing or replacing your car’s windshield if it gets damaged. This includes cracks, chips, or even if it shatters due to an object hitting it.

When objects like branches, rocks, or hail fall on your car 

If something falls onto your car, such as a tree branch, rocks kicked up by another vehicle, or hail during a storm, comprehensive insurance can cover the cost of repairing the resulting damage. It’s there for unexpected incidents that aren’t related to collisions with other vehicles.

What’s not Covered By Comprehensive Insurance?

Comprehensive insurance is quite comprehensive, but there are still some things it doesn’t cover. Here are a few examples:

  • Collision with Another Vehicle: If you collide with another car or object, that’s typically covered by collision insurance, not comprehensive.
  • Injury or Medical Expenses: Comprehensive insurance focuses on your vehicle, so it generally doesn’t cover medical expenses for injuries or bodily harm.
  • Customization and Upgrades: If you’ve made special modifications or upgrades to your car, comprehensive insurance may not cover the added value of those changes.
  • Mechanical Failures: If your car breaks down due to mechanical issues without any external cause, comprehensive insurance won’t cover the repairs.
  • Regular Maintenance: Maintenance costs, like oil changes or tire replacements, are not covered by comprehensive insurance.
  • Stolen Personal Belongings: If personal items inside your car get stolen, like a laptop or purse, comprehensive insurance usually won’t cover them. You’d need a separate renter’s or homeowner’s insurance policy for that.

Comprehensive Coverage Deductibles and Limits

When you buy comprehensive insurance, you pick an amount called a deductible. This is what you pay when you make a claim. For instance, if you choose a $500 deductible and your car is damaged by hail, costing $1,500 to fix, you pay $500, and your insurance covers the remaining $1,000.

Comprehensive coverage has a limit, which is the most it will pay for a claim. Usually, this limit is the current value of your car. So, if your car is stolen, your insurance will give you money based on its current worth, minus your deductible. If you want a newer car, you’ll probably have to use your own money on top of what the insurance gives you.

Remember, the deductible and limit for comprehensive coverage are different from those for collision coverage.

Choosing a comprehensive coverage deductible

When you get comprehensive insurance, your insurance company will give you options for deductibles, like $500, $1,000, or $1,500. If you pick a higher deductible, like $1,500, your insurance costs less every month, which saves you money right away. But if something happens to your car that’s covered by the insurance, you’ll have to pay more from your own pocket.

On the other hand, if you choose a lower deductible, like $500, your insurance costs more each month. Your agent, the person who sells you the insurance, can help you figure out which deductible and limits are best for you. It depends on what you can afford and how much risk you’re willing to take.

What is the difference between collision and comprehensive insurance?

Collision coverage takes care of fixing your car when you crash into something like another car or a fence. It’s mainly used when there’s a car accident.

Comprehensive coverage is different from collision. It helps pay for things that happen to your car that are not because of driving, like if your car gets stolen, damaged by hail, or hit by a falling tree.

How Comprehensive Auto Insurance Works

Imagine one morning, you see a big tree branch smashed your car due to a storm. Here’s how your comprehensive car insurance would help:

How Comprehensive Auto Insurance Works
  • Step 1: You take pictures of the damage and call your insurance company. They tell you they’ll pay for the repairs if you make a claim. Because you also have roadside assistance, they’ll even pay to tow your car to a repair shop.
  • Step 2: You have a $500 deductible for your comprehensive coverage, so you decide it’s worth making a claim.
  • Step 3: Your insurance company sends someone called an adjuster to check your car and estimate the repair cost. The adjuster says it’ll cost $2,900 to fix.
  • Step 4: You accept the estimate, and your insurer arranges towing to their recommended shop. You trust their choice for guaranteed repairs.
  • Step 5: With rental reimbursement in your insurance, they cover a rental car while yours is in the shop.
  • Step 6: Your car is ready for pickup. Before you drive home, pay $500 to cover your deductible.

Cost of Comprehensive Insurance

Comprehensive coverage pays for fixing your car when something bad happens, like accidents or disasters that aren’t car crashes. It can cost around $134 to $268 per year, but this varies depending on where you live.

With comprehensive and collision insurance, you choose how much you’ll pay before the insurance kicks in (called a deductible). If you don’t think you’ll need to use comprehensive insurance often, you can pick a higher deductible, like $1,000, to pay lower premiums.

The more your car is worth, the more you’ll pay for comprehensive insurance.

Insurance companies decide how much you pay based on things like where you live, your driving history, and how much coverage you want. For example, in Louisiana, it’s expensive, with drivers paying around $1,495 a year on average. But in North Dakota, it’s cheaper, with an average cost of $692 per year for car insurance.

Pros & Cons

Here’s a simplified version of the advantages and disadvantages of Comprehensive Insurance:


  • Protection from Unexpected Events: Comprehensive insurance safeguards your finances if your car is stolen, damaged by bad weather, or other major things happen that you can’t control.
  • Covers Surprises: It often pays for “unexpected events” like break-ins or damage caused by hail to your car, which can be a relief.
  • Peace of Mind for New Cars: If you own a new car and live in an area with a lot of crime, it helps cover the cost if someone breaks in or steals your car.


  • No Coverage for Collisions: Comprehensive insurance doesn’t help if you’re in a regular car accident where you hit another vehicle or object.
  • Not Needed for Older Cars: If you have an older car with a lot of miles on it, you might not need comprehensive insurance, especially if you don’t worry much about theft or bad weather where you live.
  • Doesn’t Cover Personal Items: If something personal gets stolen from your car, like a laptop or purse, this insurance won’t help.
  • Excludes Pothole Damage: Damage from potholes in the road doesn’t cover.

Comprehensive Auto Insurance: Example 

Let’s look at how comprehensive insurance works with a simple example. Imagine someone has a Honda Accord worth $10,000, and they have comprehensive insurance with a $1,000 deductible.

If a tornado wrecks their car, comprehensive insurance pays $9,000. Without it, collision and liability won’t cover tornado damage.

So, without comprehensive coverage, they would need to pay the entire $10,000 to replace the car. This might mean taking out a loan or settling for a cheaper car if they don’t have that much money on hand.

This example shows how valuable comprehensive insurance can be if something happens to your car. It’s good to understand this, especially if you’re thinking about whether to keep or drop comprehensive insurance. It helps you see what it might cost you if you have to pay for damages all by yourself.

Comprehensive Auto Insurance vs. Collision Insurance

Here’s a comparison table between Comprehensive Auto Insurance and Collision Insurance without using line breaks:

AspectComprehensive InsuranceCollision Insurance
What’s Covered– Theft, Vandalism, Natural Disasters (e.g., earthquakes, floods), Falling Objects (e.g., tree branches), Animal Collisions, Fire, Broken Windshields– Car Accidents (Collisions with other vehicles or objects)
DeductibleVariable, typically ranging from $100 to $1,000 or moreVariable, usually ranging from $250 to $1,000 or more
Coverage LimitTypically based on the actual cash value of your vehicleTypically based on the actual cash value of your vehicle
Required or Optional?Optional, but often required if financing a vehicleOptional, but often required if financing a vehicle
What’s Not Covered– Damage from regular car accidents, Medical expenses for injuries, Personal items stolen from the car, Damage due to potholes– Theft of the entire vehicle, Vandalism, Natural disasters, Damage caused by animals, Fires, and Broken Windshields – usually covered by comprehensive
Other Features– Protection against theft, weather-related events, and non-collision damages, Often covers “unexpected events” like break-ins or damage due to hail, Peace of mind for new cars in high-crime areas– Focuses on covering car accidents with other vehicles or objects, Helps pay for repairs after a collision, Less expensive compared to comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive Auto Insurance: FAQs

What is comprehensive car insurance?

Comprehensive coverage takes care of fixing your car because of damaging in accidents that aren’t collisions. Many insurance companies often ask you to get comprehensive insurance before adding collision coverage.

What does comprehensive car insurance cover?

Comprehensive car insurance covers a wide range of non-collision-related incidents that can damage your vehicle. It typically includes coverage for:

  • Theft: If your car stole, comprehensive insurance can help replace it. r cover the cost of repairs if the vehicle is recovered with damage.
  • Vandalism: If your car is intentionally damaged. such as being scratched, keyed, or spray-painted, comprehensive insurance can pay for the repairs.
  • Natural Disasters: Comprehensive insurance covers damage caused by natural disasters like earthquakes, floods, hurricanes, tornadoes, and wildfires.
  • Falling Objects: If an object like a tree branch, debris, or a rock falls on your car and causes damage, this can cover the repair costs.
  • Animal Collisions: If you hit an animal, or if an animal damages your car, comprehensive insurance can help with the repairs.
  • Fire: If your car is damaged or destroyed by a fire, whether accidental or intentional, comprehensive insurance can provide coverage.
  • Broken Glass: It covers damage to your car’s windows or windshield caused by factors other than collisions, such as a rock hitting your windshield.
  • Civil Disturbances: In case your vehicle is damaged during civil unrest or riots, comprehensive insurance may provide coverage.
  • Falling Objects: If an object falls on your car, like a tree limb or construction debris, comprehensive insurance can help pay for repairs.

Is comprehensive insurance “full coverage”?

Comprehensive insurance is a part of what is often called “full coverage” insurance, but it’s not the whole thing.

“Full coverage” typically includes liability insurance (which covers damage you cause to others) and both collision and comprehensive insurance (which cover damage to your own car). So, while comprehensive insurance is an important component of full coverage, it’s not the entire package.

Do I need comprehensive insurance?

Collision and comprehensive insurance both pay for fixing your car, but they’re for different things.

Collision insurance helps when you hit something with your car, like another car or an object.

Comprehensive insurance helps when your car gets damaged, but not because of a collision. It covers things like theft, vandalism, animal accidents, fires, and more.

Bottom Line

In conclusion, comprehensive auto insurance is a valuable addition to your car insurance coverage. It provides protection against a wide range of non-collision-related incidents. This includes theft, vandalism, natural disasters, falling objects, animal collisions, fires, and broken windshields. 

Leave a Reply